Strike Sheet: Big Bronx XXXVIII
NEW YORK, N.Y. — Jon Cruz released today the list of critics for the Lincoln-Douglas Debate Tournament at the thirty-eighth annual New York City Invitational. His e-mail follows.
—
We will be using a community preference system in the Lincoln-Douglas Debate division to give coaches input into the rating of the judges used at our tournament. A community preference system determines each judge’s rating by averaging the ratings submitted by all programs.
“A” judges will adjudicate “bubble rounds” (down 1 or 2), as these are the debaters still in contention for elimination rounds. “C” judges, then, are better placed where the stakes are less high. “Bs” fit where they fit.
We do not impose a limit on ratings in our Lincoln-Douglas Debate tournament; you may rate as many as you want whatever you want. You may strike up to eight judges.
*** IMPORTANT *** The completed sheet must be sent to Jim Menick, our director of tabulation for Lincoln-Douglas Debate, by 7:00 PM on Thursday. Jim can be reached at jim_menick@yahoo.com.
If a judge is missing from this rating sheet, please contact Jon Cruz.
Any other questions? Please e-mail Jim Menick.
E-mail this sheet back to Jim Menick. You may rate judges 1 for A, 2 for B, 3 for C. Write STRIKE for judges you are striking. Judge constraints do not count as strikes, but please indicate if a particular judge is constrained from judging your school.
NOTE: Mira Chernick, Mike Contillo, Molly Pittman, and Brandon Sherman were added to the sheet after the initial version was sent out to coaches. They have been added this list.
My apologies, there are three final additions to the sheet. Any other judges that are added will be listed on a supplementary strike sheet this Friday. (Supplementary strike sheets are “free” strikes.)
___ Abel, Marta (Ridge)
___ Abid, Maeshal (Pace)
___ Alston, Jonathan (Newark Science)
___ Beretay, Abdul (Byram Hills/University)
___ Berger, Mike (Lakeville North)
___ Berringer, Ben ‘03 (Bronx Science)
___ Bigman, Jared (Lake Braddock)
___ Breyter, Kristin Martin ‘02 (Bronx Science/Arthur L. Johnson)
___ Castillo, Chris (Altamont)
___ Cata, Nicole (Hendrick Hudson)
___ Chernick, Mira (formerly Lexington) [Hired]
___ Choudhury, Anjan (Walt Whitman)
___ Conrad, Neil (Greenhill) [Hired]
___ Contillo, Mike (Perkiomen Valley)
___ Craven, Wesley (South Eugene)
___ Daily, Carrie (Perry)
___ Diehl, Patrick (Scarsdale)
___ Eller, Melanie (Saint James)
___ Erickson, Courtney (Lakeville North)
___ Feig, Vivian (Walt Whitman)
___ Fielder, Cody (California)
___ Fleeger, Kyle (Desert Vista)
___ Garvin, Andrew (formerly Mission San Jose) [Hired]
___ Gil-Montllor, Petey (Trinity Prep)
___ Glickstein, Jed (formerly Edina) [Hired]
___ Guzman, Arianna (Lake Highland)
___ Halpern, Caitlin (Stuyvesant) [Hired]
___ Hansen, Rebecca (Whippany Park)
___ Hantel, Max (Potomac)
___ Haver, Maureen (formerly Houston-Memorial) [Hired]
___ Hertzig, Chetan (formerly Sacred Heart) [Hired]
___ Holzer, Mike (Lake Highland)
___ Jennis, Dan (Morristown)
___ Johnson, Gary (Strake Jesuit)
___ Kaczmarek, Sheryl (Newburgh Free) ** TAB **
___ Kelley, Samantha (Hendrick Hudson)
___ Koshy, Cherian (Apple Valley) [Hired]
___ Lee, Peter (Palo Alto)
___ Levi, Jacob (formerly Berkeley Carroll) [Hired]
___ Lewis, John (formerly Houston-Memorial) [Hired]
___ Liipfert, Todd (Walt Whitman)
___ Liverzani, Amanda (formerly Meadows) [Hired]
___ Martinez, Randall (Christopher Columbus)
___ Massey, Hasan (Monticello)
___ McGrath, Larry (formerly Presentation) [Hired]
___ McMillan, Fianah (Newark Science)
___ Menick, Jim (Hendrick Hudson) ** TAB **
___ Michals, Nicole (Whippany Park)
___ Morris, Kyle (Kinkaid)
___ O’Connell, Michael (Carnegie Vanguard)
___ Pak, Andrew ‘96 (Bronx Science)
___ Pittman, Molly (Isidore Newman)
___ Plaza, Melanie ‘08 (Bronx Science)
___ Ramakrishnan, Deepa (Chicago Latin) [Hired]
___ Roberts, Jeff (Mountain Brook)
___ Rollins, Tom (Potomac)
___ Russell, Jo (formerly Edmond North) [Hired]
___ Rye, Jay (Montgomery)
___ Savage, Jennie (Palo Alto)
___ Sheehan, Daniel (Palo Alto)
___ Sherman, Brandon (formerly Millburn) [Hired]
___ Steiker, Diane D. (Byram Hills)
___ Stickley, Allison (Iowa City)
___ Sun, Jason (Vestavia Hills)
___ Syed, Sohail (Arthur L. Johnson)
___ Tam, Elizabeth ‘06 (Bronx Science)
___ Tarsney, Christian (Saint Louis Park)
___ Thomas, Stacy (Hockaday)
___ Thorsen, J.R. (Lake Highland)
___ Topal-Teleky, Michelle ‘99 (Bronx Science)
___ Vaughan, Joe (Scarsdale)
___ Vohra, Taarini (Bronx Science)
___ Volek, Jude ‘99 (Bronx Science)
___ Wallach, Marc (Millburn)
___ Ward, Anna (formerly Monte Vista) [Hired]
___ Webber, Mark (IDEA, formerly Houston-Memorial) [Hired]
___ Werner, Andy (Hockaday)
___ Zaleznik, Daniel (Lexington)
___ Zhang, Min (formerly Archer) [Hired]
Popularity: 4%
no more tag found, sorry
55 Responses to “Strike Sheet: Big Bronx XXXVIII”
Leave a Reply
Most Popular Posts
- Jake Nebel Wins Big Bronx XXXVIII
- Chris Theis Claims Second St. Mark's Title
- BREAKING NEWS: It's Felons
- Alex Koren Wins UPenn
- Cameron Baghai Wins the Tedd Wood
- Debating the Merits of the Current Debate Topic
- Ilya Gaidarov Wins CSU Long Beach Title
- Field Report: The Kaiser
- In a Close Out, Scarsdale Takes the Kaiser
- Strike Sheet: Big Bronx XXXVIII
Posted from: 69.120.236.168
October 20th, 2008 20:22
Very good judging pool. Except for Menick. He’s an auto-C judge (I run on reciprocation).
Posted from: 68.104.1.44
October 21st, 2008 07:37
No limit on ratings? Not that we’re attending, but we could rate everyone a C except for 8 As and be guaranteed those judges all tournament…?
Posted from: 68.104.1.44
October 21st, 2008 07:37
No limit on ratings? Not that we’re attending, but we could rate everyone a C except for 8 As and be guaranteed those judges all tournament…?
Posted from: 68.104.1.44
October 21st, 2008 07:37
Sorry for the 2x post. Don’t know how that happened.
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 21st, 2008 10:06
It’s community ratings, not MJP. So, all your ratings do is provide one data point that when collected over the entire set provide a judge’s “average” — that aveerage determines/assists in judge placement (rather than tab solely determining judge placement or random judge placement). In other words, the ratings give a collective sense of what the participants think about the judges. I applaud Bronx for doing it.
In other important news, every team gets eight strikes — I HIGHLY RECOMMEND YOU USE ONE OF THOSE ON ANJAN CHOUDHURY (WALT WHITMAN). I hear he is a terrible judge and a total hack. Definitely strike him.
Posted from: 130.212.18.56
October 21st, 2008 12:26
A shout out to Cody Fielder, Zhuchen Zu, and the California High School team. We look forward to seeing you in New York! Give me a call if you need anything.
Posted from: 141.161.179.193
October 21st, 2008 13:29
Due to working for Whitman, I have been compelled to suggest that you strike Anjan Choudhury.
Posted from: 148.85.225.81
October 21st, 2008 13:30
“I agree with above, you should strike Anjan”
- Anjan
Posted from: 128.101.230.243
October 21st, 2008 13:34
I want to use all 8 of our strikes on Anjan!
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 21st, 2008 13:36
If you support Obama, you should strike Anjan.
If you support McCain, you should strike Choudhury.
If you are undecided, you should strike both Anjan and Choudhury.
Posted from: 72.213.162.95
October 21st, 2008 13:56
Hey, on a different note, isn’t the topic analysis supposed to be out today?
Posted from: 68.104.1.44
October 21st, 2008 13:58
Again, we’re not attending… But if we were, we would strike Anjan both on the strike sheet and physically.
I’d also have a student spit food at him.
Posted from: 165.123.230.154
October 21st, 2008 14:03
If you’re smart, you really should strike Anjan.
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 21st, 2008 14:09
Ali is right! I haven’t flowed since I was a rap star!
STRIKE ANJAN. ITS WHAT THE COOL KIDS ARE DOING.
Posted from: 66.240.26.33
October 21st, 2008 14:11
It’s unfortunate that there is no yearly strike sheet, because we’d drop Anjan like it’s hot.
real hot.
Posted from: 72.213.162.95
October 21st, 2008 14:20
Hey, on a different note, isn’t the topic analysis supposed to be out today?
Posted from: 206.180.133.78
October 21st, 2008 14:27
Anjan killed our hopes and dreams RD 7 at Glenbrooks last year. If I had to do it again, I’d strike him.
Posted from: 206.180.133.79
October 21st, 2008 14:34
Re Posts 11 & 16
“She’s looking at you. Ah, no, no, she’s looking at me.”
Posted from: 98.195.66.198
October 21st, 2008 14:42
how many judges are people allowed to physically strike?
Posted from: 68.11.25.35
October 21st, 2008 14:51
“Hey, I want to be Bob Dylan.”
Posted from: 72.213.162.95
October 21st, 2008 15:07
Clever Sam. Seriously though, I would like to receive those briefs soon, and there supposed to be out today.
Posted from: 24.13.173.119
October 21st, 2008 16:08
according to the tentative schedule of release dates
Posted from: 72.213.162.95
October 21st, 2008 16:24
Correct, though I was not aware of ‘tentative’.
Posted from: 70.116.19.103
October 22nd, 2008 21:04
seriously, strike anjan. we’re not joking.
Posted from: 174.148.96.250
October 22nd, 2008 21:04
dude. I used to debate against anjan and everytime he opened his mouth I was like WTF? what an idiot. I mean he qualified for State in DI!!! if there were ever a legit reason to strike a person it would be now. plus he is a scarsdale hack…so no one else stands a chance anyway
love you man
Posted from: 70.138.96.26
October 22nd, 2008 21:06
strike anjan
Posted from: 98.218.230.121
October 22nd, 2008 21:07
For those keeping score:
_STRIKE_ Anjan Choudhury (Walt Whitman)
Its not just an action, its a movement.
Posted from: 128.135.208.120
October 22nd, 2008 21:11
By far the worst judge…EVER
strike Anjan
if you’re confused
_STRIKE_ Anjan Choudhury (Walt Whitman)
Posted from: 147.9.227.72
October 22nd, 2008 21:14
As someone who coaches with him, I highly advise you to STRIKE ANJAN CHOUDHURY
Posted from: 71.191.251.116
October 22nd, 2008 21:20
strike Anjan
Posted from: 98.14.255.196
October 22nd, 2008 21:24
Anjan is being consistently ranked an “A.” Good work!
Posted from: 69.151.227.213
October 22nd, 2008 21:28
I want to be struck too.
pumpkin face raisin face!
Posted from: 98.218.230.121
October 22nd, 2008 21:34
This is just voter intimidation. Don’t buy into the negative lies from CRUZ.
STRIKE ANJAN IN 2008, YOU KNOW YOU WANT TO.
This is a change we can believe in!
Posted from: 67.186.7.181
October 22nd, 2008 21:36
strike anjan he’s a big gimp
Posted from: 76.212.197.234
October 22nd, 2008 21:49
I agree with Chris Castillo. Strike Anjan based on Pumpkin face Rasin face
Posted from: 168.122.212.114
October 22nd, 2008 22:00
nobody should waste their strike on me; i’m only judging on saturday.
but everyone should definitely strike anjan
Posted from: 75.56.210.18
October 22nd, 2008 22:05
I’ll be cool like the cool kids and strike Anjan, even though I’m not going…
Posted from: 69.253.230.13
October 23rd, 2008 03:37
anjan told me he’s giving every debater a L20. strike him.
Posted from: 209.181.228.22
October 23rd, 2008 05:28
Strike Anjan!
pumpkin face raisin face!
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 23rd, 2008 08:27
Imagine what kind of person is NOT striking Anjan at this point. Then, think to your self:
Self, if I end up facing this kind of person, do I really want to do so with Anjan judging.
STRIKE ANJAN IN 2008. EARLY AND OFTEN.
Posted from: 128.135.197.215
October 23rd, 2008 08:33
strike anjan man, he would rather be eating in n out than listening to you.
Posted from: 137.52.211.175
October 23rd, 2008 08:34
If I were going I’d strike Anjan. I hear he sleeps in rounds. He also hacks for his friends.
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 23rd, 2008 08:35
Not only do I hack for my friends, but I am not friends with people who refuse to strike me.
Posted from: 70.184.29.2
October 23rd, 2008 11:48
Im not striking Anjan. He’s really cool!
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 23rd, 2008 12:03
If you think I am cool, then let me hang out in the cafeteria — STRIKE ME.
STRIKE ANJAN, ITS THE MAVERICK THING TO DO, DOGGONE IT.
Posted from: 70.184.29.2
October 23rd, 2008 12:31
Oh fine, but pick me up a burger.
Posted from: 141.161.179.50
October 23rd, 2008 12:32
no seriously,
Anjan has judged so many rounds on this topic that he has decided whether the resolution is true or false, and that is the side that you won’t be defending.
Posted from: 150.212.20.117
October 23rd, 2008 12:35
IT’S A PLOY. RUN.
Posted from: 67.181.192.175
October 23rd, 2008 13:01
Oh Rebar, the line is “It’s a trap!”. And in this instance, it isn’t.
All things said about Anjan here are true: he does sleep in rounds, he also works in rounds (not on debate though), he decides the outcomes of rounds prior to pairings being released, when he does pay attention he usually makes the wrong decision, he hates evidence but also hates slow debate, he hates theory but loves RVIs, he also gives double 20s with great frequency.
And, he’s not lying, the only way to be friends with Anjan is to strike him. We struck him at Greenhill and he payed for part of my meal.
Posted from: 69.140.171.79
October 23rd, 2008 13:01
Maybe if you rank Anjan high enough, he’ll have to judge every single round at the tournament. We won’t need any other judges. Imagine the money you’ll save!
Posted from: 67.181.192.175
October 23rd, 2008 13:02
Ouch, *paid. Man, that’s bad.
Posted from: 208.118.184.3
October 23rd, 2008 13:07
And the meal was at Fogo de Chao! How’s that for your TASTES OF THE WORLD.
Ben Lewis, you are grounded. Go sit in the corner.
Posted from: 69.140.158.182
October 23rd, 2008 13:12
Anjan flows in boxes…
Three of them.
s-s-s-s-s-strike!
Posted from: 98.201.177.133
October 23rd, 2008 15:19
anjan will bill his clients while judging you. strike him.
strike chris castillo too; he votes solely on rep. as do i. as does anjan.
Posted from: 199.74.70.207
October 23rd, 2008 17:55
I will not be judging as the debater I coach is sick and will not be attending