Stephen Hess Wins VBT@Archer
posted by Bietz on January 8th, 2006
SANTA MONICA, CA - Congratulations to the finalists at this year’s Victory Briefs Tournament at the Archer School for Girls! After breaking to double-octafinals, Mountain View High School’s Stephen Hess and Hockaday School’s A.J. Motgi won the necessary outrounds to guarantee their place as the last two debaters standing. In the final round, Stephen defeated A.J. to claim this year’s VBT title.
Stephen Hess is coached by Eric Palmer, Navot Tidhar, and Kiwi Camara. A.J. is coached by Stacy Thomas and Tom Evnen.
Popularity: 2%
test
148 Responses to “Stephen Hess Wins VBT@Archer”
Leave a Reply
Most Popular Posts
- Debate History: A Spotlight on the Barkley Forum Tutorials
- Intelligently Designed: The January 2006 Public Forum Anaylsis and Briefs
- Matt Shields Wins the MBA Round Robin
- Celebrating Our National Qualifiers
- Welcome Home to VBD v4.0!
- Jon Gordon Takes Home Columbia
- Douglas Jeffers Wins the Barkley Forum
- Stephen Hess Wins VBT@Archer
- Corbin Cass Wins Colleyville Heritage
- J.R. Thorsen Claims the Crestian
Posted from: 70.146.83.139
January 7th, 2006 11:28
gosh i love rashmi rikhy.
Posted from: 24.6.81.188
January 7th, 2006 12:50
good luck and special hugs to nad nad!!
Posted from: 205.188.117.11
January 7th, 2006 13:52
are mba pods available anywhere?
Posted from: 66.243.100.161
January 7th, 2006 14:30
There are no pods at MBA, there are 11 rounds.
Posted from: 68.90.224.173
January 7th, 2006 15:51
Any results from mba rr?
Posted from: 68.90.224.173
January 7th, 2006 15:56
Any results from mba rr?
Posted from: 71.139.162.252
January 7th, 2006 17:05
Try posting round 4 again — seems to be blank.
Posted from: 69.151.206.147
January 7th, 2006 17:37
Please fix Round 4 result, it’s blank–thanks!!!
Posted from: 64.232.127.190
January 7th, 2006 17:44
mba doesnt permit disclosure. demo round gets announced after lunch tomorrow.
Posted from: 24.6.59.211
January 7th, 2006 18:30
Hahahahahahahha MSJ is…MSJ!
What ever happened to OHSODEF?
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 7th, 2006 18:33
Lex JZ is up 4 confirmed and is hitting aj now. (rd 5)
Go Jason go!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 19:58
Dave McGinnes a totally devoted coach to Lynnbrooook!!!!!!! As for a judge ???????????
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 20:01
Dave McGinnes a totally devoted coach to Lynnbrooook, but as for a judge ???????????
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 20:47
Gi, you’re rit. I checked the 5 rounds. Dave have judged 4 rounds(all together 8 pairs), 5 pairs of them have MSJ debater. That’s a loooooot,rit. Well, at least he got all MSJ kids’ case flowed for his kiddos, that works for him. MSJ is dying. Why does he bother?!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 20:55
Gi, you’re rit. I checked the 5 rounds. Dave has judged 4(A & B flight)rounds(all together 8 pairs), 5 pairs of them have a MSJ debater. That’s funny. Well, at least he got all MSJ kids’ cases flowed for his kiddos, that works for him. MSJ is dying. Why does he bother?! What a shame for debate!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 21:15
Hmmmmmmmmmmm!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 21:16
Hmmmmmmmmmmm!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 21:32
Go Bobby Holly!
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 7th, 2006 21:32
Go Bobby Holly!
Posted from: 4.252.28.38
January 7th, 2006 22:26
good luck to everyone at the tournament!
Posted from: 4.252.28.38
January 7th, 2006 22:27
good luck to everyone at the tournament!
Posted from: 12.145.154.226
January 7th, 2006 23:48
hi mr. hogan
Posted from: 71.131.7.250
January 8th, 2006 00:02
saw mcginnes in black. he is kind of crazy.
Posted from: 24.6.59.211
January 8th, 2006 02:08
Hey Post #23 wasn’t posted by me. I don’t know mcginnes, nor am i even at the tournament. #23 used my name and email though. what a douchebag.
Posted from: 24.90.97.209
January 8th, 2006 02:46
Good Luck Peter!
Posted from: 66.108.83.214
January 8th, 2006 07:12
Andrew Phillips = coolest little brother ever.
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 08:22
lex jz 5-0 hitting ali now.
omg jason keep it up!
Posted from: 68.196.115.198
January 8th, 2006 09:08
SHIT JASON’S DOING AWESOME!
keep it up kiddo. ndf reprezent.
Posted from: 68.198.158.134
January 8th, 2006 10:01
J-Z:
I get my, “by any means on”,
wheneva there’s a drought;
get ya umbrellas out
because, that’s when I brainstorm
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 10:30
Breaks are out.
lex jz hits strake jesuit so in dubs
Posted from: 66.108.83.214
January 8th, 2006 10:51
Bronx Science PP vs. Trinity Prep RS
Posted from: 71.131.93.142
January 8th, 2006 10:58
post breaks please!
Posted from: 71.131.93.142
January 8th, 2006 10:58
post breaks please!
Posted from: 67.161.35.149
January 8th, 2006 10:58
how come we haven’t gotten any update today???
Posted from: 65.66.219.130
January 8th, 2006 11:12
Please update/or post breaks…thanks!
Posted from: 66.174.79.231
January 8th, 2006 11:15
I’m judging Strake Jesuit SO (aff) vs Lexington JZ (neg).
Trinity Prep RS vs. Bronx PP
Lexington JZ vs. Strake Jesuit SO
Hockaday RB vs. Bellarmine BH
Redlands JH vs. Homestead VR
Highland Park DW vs. La Reina CT
Kinkaid BT vs. WT Woodson CH
Westlake RC vs. South Eugene JS
Menlo BR vs. Lynbrook CC
Hockaday AjM vs. Strake Jesuit JC
Rancho Bernardo KP vs. Immac AK
Strake Jesuit AW vs. Meadows DD
Meadows MS vs. Berkeley Carroll PD
Hollis Brookline AH vs. La Jolla ES
Mountain View SH vs. Strake Jesuit DD
Strake Jesuit PM vs. Menlo SA
Lynbrook PD vs. Hockaday JZ
Flip for sides.
Posted from: 12.226.91.74
January 8th, 2006 11:24
GL to Eric Sefton, the kid is a stud.
GL to Hess, that man is pretty.
Posted from: 70.146.83.139
January 8th, 2006 11:27
yay this rocks
good luck to eric sefton, weeks, claire, spirtos, and everyone else.
Posted from: 70.114.9.107
January 8th, 2006 11:28
g’luck to the hockaday contingent and especially jz.
also to cooper, werner, spirtos and my big jewtower friend…
Posted from: 67.42.94.243
January 8th, 2006 11:32
Good luck to Peter Damrosckshsf (McKay/Case represent!) and Jeremy Schifberg (7th Flo’ Crew JS)
Posted from: 66.174.92.162
January 8th, 2006 11:39
Lexington JZ defeated Strake Jesuit SO 2-1 (Peiris, Boyle*, Jain)
Posted from: 69.107.77.208
January 8th, 2006 11:51
yeah lynbrook representing good luck patrick and cynthia!
Posted from: 216.100.32.10
January 8th, 2006 11:58
Jason is a beast. Congrats buddy - here’s hoping it rubs off on me next weekend. :P
The rest of you in doubs and beyond are pretty cool, too…wish I was there, if only to watch some of those rounds.
~Ankur
Posted from: 66.174.79.230
January 8th, 2006 12:06
Ashan wants me to add that Jason is “hella baller”.
Posted from: 205.188.117.11
January 8th, 2006 12:12
don’t want to divert attention away from VBT, but if anyone is interested:
LD Demo Round: Shields vs. Levi
Extemp Exhibition Round: Dan Rauch, Charlie Alderman, Josh Rovenger
Good luck and congrats to all!
Posted from: 70.241.127.243
January 8th, 2006 12:20
ryan cooper is a beast
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 12:28
Yayyy Jason!!!!
Congrats to Shields and Jacob at MBA.
And Jason appreciates his “baller baller” fo’ real status.
Posted from: 68.198.150.207
January 8th, 2006 12:36
Congrats to Shields and Charlie!
Good luck to everyone at VBT!
Posted from: 66.174.79.230
January 8th, 2006 12:37
Trinity Prep RS def Bronx PP 3-0 (Peiris, Boyle, Jain)
Posted from: 70.157.206.236
January 8th, 2006 12:44
Congrats so far/good luck in the rest of the tournament to Ravi.
Posted from: 68.198.150.207
January 8th, 2006 13:08
I know Jon Cruz isn’t there, but can someone post full pairings and judge panels for doubles and octos if it’s out yet…?
Posted from: 66.174.93.98
January 8th, 2006 13:14
Octos -
(Flip)
Hockaday AjM vs. Meadows MS (Johnson, Case, Cheng)
Hollis-Brookline AH vs. Homestead VR (Peiris, Sheehan, Boyle)
Lynbrook PD vs. Trinity Prep RS (Huynh, Tidhar, McGrath)
Menlo BR vs. Highland Park DW (Clancy, S. Smith, McGinnis)
Mountain View SH vs. Bellarmine BH (Choudhury, Majikian, Myers)
Rancho Bernardo KP vs. Strake Jesuit AW (Gil, Sidhu, Cottam)
Strake Jesuit PM vs. Lexington JZ (Parker, Brugato, Jones)
Westlake RC vs. Kinkaid BT (Lawrence, Zaleznik, Paccioti)
Posted from: 71.250.58.6
January 8th, 2006 13:21
dan rauch is good at extemp.
Posted from: 68.126.218.12
January 8th, 2006 13:30
good luck byron, and congrats sophie!
Posted from: 24.13.82.229
January 8th, 2006 13:36
just wondering if myers is Dan Meyers, probably just a typo, but i just wanted to know…
Good Luck to DWeeks and Spirtos!
Posted from: 70.146.83.100
January 8th, 2006 13:41
good luck to my boy spirtos, shess, and p diehl
Posted from: 66.26.67.103
January 8th, 2006 13:45
Is Ravi Sankar and Peter Damrosch facing each other?
I think the outcome will be
Hockaday AjM
Homestead VR
Lynbrook PD
Highland Park DW
Bellarmine BH
Strake Jesuit AW
Lexington JZ (sorry Patrick)
Westlake RC
Posted from: 66.26.67.103
January 8th, 2006 13:48
I THINK finals will be Anjali and Jason or Andy taking one of their places
Any differ?
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 13:49
Lynbrook PD isn’t Peter Damrosch (who’s from Berkely Caroll)
Good Luck Jason! and of course hess.
Posted from: 63.201.142.97
January 8th, 2006 14:23
good luck byron! and <3 for sophie!
Posted from: 69.3.94.183
January 8th, 2006 14:34
Can someone please post Quarters rounds ASAP? -thanks
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 15:02
Lex JZ drops in octas…
and apparently Hess is hitting Cooper in Quarters.
Go hess Go hess Go hess Go hess!
Posted from: 69.3.94.183
January 8th, 2006 15:15
anyone know about patrick diehl???
Posted from: 70.241.127.243
January 8th, 2006 15:57
coooooooop.
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 16:09
Hess picks up.
YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY HESS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted from: 209.6.251.133
January 8th, 2006 16:12
Oh also– AJ picks up against Patrick Diehl (I think)
and Allison was hitting Menlo BR…dno the outcome of that rd yet
Posted from: 216.100.32.10
January 8th, 2006 16:14
huge congrats to hess on his first bid. You definitely deserved it, and it’s really awesome to finally see the breakthrough!
~Ankur
Posted from: 71.198.176.41
January 8th, 2006 16:28
Thanks Sonia- see if you can get a posting?
Go Byron- congradulations and good luck to Stephen! - anybody know about Vinitha?
Posted from: 69.151.232.32
January 8th, 2006 16:38
There go the strake boys again…
Posted from: 69.151.232.32
January 8th, 2006 16:38
There go the strake boys again…
Posted from: 69.151.232.32
January 8th, 2006 16:39
there go the strake boys again
Posted from: 69.107.77.208
January 8th, 2006 16:48
can someone post quarters/semis pairings?
and anybody know what happened to lynbrook pd
Posted from: 68.252.244.195
January 8th, 2006 16:50
Congrats to Hess… i don’t know anyone more deserving of this…
Posted from: 71.106.1.246
January 8th, 2006 16:57
quarters
hockaday ajm over lynbrook pd
menlo br over hollis ah
strake jesuit pm over rancho bernardo kp
moutain view sh over westlake rc
semis
strake pm forfeits to moutain view sh
menlo br debates hockaday ajm
Posted from: 68.198.150.207
January 8th, 2006 17:17
YES! YES! YES!
Congrats to Byron and Hess! So well-deserved for both of you! So well-deserved!!!
Out of curiousity, why did Mahoney forfeit to Hess…?
Posted from: 69.214.106.1
January 8th, 2006 17:24
CONGRATS HESSS
good job + what lumps said
Posted from: 68.196.115.198
January 8th, 2006 17:25
GO HESS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and aj of course ;)!
Posted from: 71.141.21.115
January 8th, 2006 17:28
Awesome job Byron, and congratulations on getting a bid.
Posted from: 70.114.9.107
January 8th, 2006 17:28
Sems:
hockaday aj def menlo br on a 5-0
mountain view over strake jesuit pm (concession bc of flight)
finals:
hockaday aj vs. mountain view sh
rematch of ndf tournament quarterfinals…
Posted from: 70.114.9.107
January 8th, 2006 17:33
Sems:
hockaday AjM def. Menlo BR on a 5-0
Mountain view SH over Strake Jesuit PM (concession due to patrick having to have to catch a flight)
finals:
Hockaday AjM v. Mountain View SH
yea rematch of ndf quarterfinals
Posted from: 66.26.67.103
January 8th, 2006 17:41
That sucks that Patrick had to leave, I never get why coaches get flights before rounds, especially when their debaters have a good chance of breaking. Maybe they just couldn’t get any other huh? Anyway congrats to all breaking!
Posted from: 59.95.160.188
January 8th, 2006 17:47
Yay Aaaaaj and Mr. Hess! Congrats!
Posted from: 71.139.162.252
January 8th, 2006 17:52
Congratulations, Byron! Way to go! — Your sister
Posted from: 68.126.218.12
January 8th, 2006 17:55
yayyyy byron! good job
Posted from: 66.26.67.103
January 8th, 2006 17:59
That sucks that Patrick had to leave, I never get why coaches get flights before rounds, especially when their debaters have a good chance of breaking. Maybe they just couldn’t get any other huh? Anyway congrats to all breaking!
Posted from: 71.131.93.142
January 8th, 2006 18:06
where was the bid?
Posted from: 69.151.232.32
January 8th, 2006 18:12
he had to get that flight because they couldn’t miss anymore school.
Posted from: 65.12.227.240
January 8th, 2006 18:12
semis
Posted from: 67.188.80.58
January 8th, 2006 18:20
Congrats to everyone who cleared, and especially to AJ and Shess for being in finals!
Posted from: 67.188.80.58
January 8th, 2006 18:22
Congrats to everyone who cleared, and especially to AJ and Shess for being in finals!
Posted from: 207.172.150.102
January 8th, 2006 18:28
Byron-
I love you man! Congratulations!
Posted from: 69.230.130.233
January 8th, 2006 18:32
Congrats to Byron for breaking his VBT curse and getting some well deserved speaks, and to Sophie for getting a trophy to go with those mad skillz.
Respect to Ryan Cooper for doing so well on his vacation.
And big ups to A.J. for continuing her *very* successful year with yet another top performance!
Posted from: 66.26.67.103
January 8th, 2006 18:33
Hey guys i dont have the finals verdict but even better
I saved a lot of money by switchin to GEICO DIRECT!!!!!!!
Posted from: 70.146.83.100
January 8th, 2006 18:38
YES SHESS
Posted from: 69.230.130.233
January 8th, 2006 18:42
Congrats to Byron for breaking the VBT curse and getting some well deserved speaker points, and congrats to Sophie for getting a trophy to go with her mad skillz.
Respect to Ryan Cooper for doing so well on his vacation.
And big ups to A.J. for another top performance in a *very* successful year.
Posted from: 68.196.115.198
January 8th, 2006 18:54
well, i guess ill attempt to answer the questions about strake taking an earlier flight. im not sure if this is the real reason cuz aj is still in but w/e, im going to say it anyways. tfa state rules state that u can’t miss over i think 3 sundays a season due to tournaments or u lose ur qualification to the tfa state tournament. this is why corbin and mahoney had a coin flip at ut finals and numerous other tournaments are only friday/sat.
so yay for debate “blue laws”! yay for only competing on 3 sundays! yay for tfa being too lazy to change it!
w00t w00t
<3 panda
Posted from: 67.9.116.255
January 8th, 2006 19:02
The sunday rule panda talked about isn’t a TFA rule. Its a UIL rule. UIL is different group with a different set of rules, and usually the one that school districts concern themselves with when it comes to budgets.
Posted from: 64.232.127.190
January 8th, 2006 19:06
Hess won on a 3-2. Hella congrats on a long, long, long due win. Also congrats to AJ and Byron.
Posted from: 70.114.9.107
January 8th, 2006 19:15
YAY FOR HESS AND AJ!!!
mad good job on the win!!!
Posted from: 66.174.93.103
January 8th, 2006 19:17
For those of us doing some airport quarterbacking ;) , what was the finals panel if anyone knows (and the 3-2 split)?
Posted from: 169.231.12.193
January 8th, 2006 19:17
madd props to hess, aj, byron, and the real diehl for intense weekends.
Posted from: 68.117.35.53
January 8th, 2006 19:28
byron is the man. congrats.
Posted from: 68.252.244.195
January 8th, 2006 19:33
Congrats to Hess winning the VBT… what a pimp.. also congrats to AJ for being runner up.
Posted from: 71.106.97.104
January 8th, 2006 19:40
The decision had ryan lawrence and shyaam subramanian (sorry if i totally butchered that spelling) on bottom.
daniel sheehan, adwait parker, and tim case were on top.
it was a very, very close round, and even the rfd’s from the people on top said that they were about 10 seconds away from voting for aj.
Posted from: 69.249.91.131
January 8th, 2006 19:40
congrats to byron, who puts so much time into debate; I’m really glad that he finally has some well-deserved success
Posted from: 162.83.209.217
January 8th, 2006 19:47
Congrats peter for clearing.
Posted from: 70.241.72.62
January 8th, 2006 19:55
“well, i guess ill attempt to answer the questions about strake taking an earlier flight. im not sure if this is the real reason cuz aj is still in but w/e, im going to say it anyways. tfa state rules state that u can’t miss over i think 3 sundays a season due to tournaments or u lose ur qualification to the tfa state tournament. this is why corbin and mahoney had a coin flip at ut finals and numerous other tournaments are only friday/sat.
so yay for debate “blue laws”! yay for only competing on 3 sundays! yay for tfa being too lazy to change it!
w00t w00t
<3 panda”
That is horribly wrong.
1. TFA has no Sunday rule (as Rene said it is the UIL rule)
2. THe reason Corbin and Mahoney flipped was NOT because of the Sunday rule but because TFA has a rule that says you can’t debate a round that starts after midnight. However, Corbin and Mahoney could have debated at 7am the next morning and it would have been fine (i.e. Dulles has semis and finals on Sunday morning).
3. It isn’t even 3 Sundays; it is 2 Sundays.
Congratz to Byron on his bid and everyone else. Looks like a fun tournament and it sucks I had to miss it. :(
Posted from: 70.241.72.62
January 8th, 2006 19:57
“well, i guess ill attempt to answer the questions about strake taking an earlier flight. im not sure if this is the real reason cuz aj is still in but w/e, im going to say it anyways. tfa state rules state that u can’t miss over i think 3 sundays a season due to tournaments or u lose ur qualification to the tfa state tournament. this is why corbin and mahoney had a coin flip at ut finals and numerous other tournaments are only friday/sat.
so yay for debate “blue laws”! yay for only competing on 3 sundays! yay for tfa being too lazy to change it!
w00t w00t
<3 panda”
That is horribly wrong.
1. TFA has no Sunday rule (as Rene said it is the UIL rule)
2. THe reason Corbin and Mahoney flipped was NOT because of the Sunday rule but because TFA has a rule that says you can’t debate a round that starts after midnight. However, Corbin and Mahoney could have debated at 7am the next morning and it would have been fine (i.e. Dulles has semis and finals on Sunday morning).
3. It isn’t even 3 Sundays; it is 2 Sundays.
Congratz to Byron on his bid and everyone else. Looks like a fun tournament and it sucks I had to miss it. :(
Posted from: 130.132.143.49
January 8th, 2006 20:10
it still leaves the question unanswered. why did they leave early?>!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
Posted from: 70.251.65.93
January 8th, 2006 20:52
dude i could have added more strake victories to my wal. HOW DARE THEY
Posted from: 138.23.53.171
January 9th, 2006 00:19
i love you kevin pratt.
Posted from: 12.45.167.28
January 9th, 2006 05:00
We left early because our school has very strict policies about missing school. We would not have been allowed to go if we were were to miss any school. The flight we were on did not leave until 6:50 and was the last one of the evening. If we would have waited we would have missed school today and would be in trouble. Leaving early didn’t detract from the experience, it was still a great tournament.
Posted from: 66.208.26.115
January 9th, 2006 06:00
On behalf of a team that came all the way from the East Coast (W.T. Woodson), I just wanted to say thanks to Victor and Mike Bietz. Not only was the weather amazing, the tournament and round robin was a lot of fun. The schedule was relaxed enough to be both humane and reasonable, the competition was great, and the judging pool was deep. Not to mention the fact that all the Archer and Brentwood team/parents were really gracious hosts, and the director’s chairs were pretty cool tropies. I hope some more East Coast schools decide to take the trip out to L.A. next January — I mean, seriously, 70 degrees and sunny!
Also, big props to A.J. who was seriously impressive in both rounds I judged her! Her round with Danielle from the Meadows School was far and away the best round I have seen on this topic (and one of the best of the year!) in both skill and engaging the substance of the resolution — wow! It was good to be back out in Cali again!
p.s. Happy Birthday Bietz!
Posted from: 207.80.127.250
January 9th, 2006 09:00
Dear “justwannaknow”,
It seems we have something in common. I would also like to know. I want to know who the hell you are and what sort of psychic, magical, or alien powers that can determine the outcome of rounds. Really, I would like to take you to Vegas and we will bet on the horses together (except I’ll bet on the ones you say will lose).
For one thing, you weren’t there, so you weren’t in out rounds and you don’t know how well anyone was debating this tournament. If you warrant your arguments this well in rounds, then I doubt anyone will be making any (winning) predictions about you in the future. For another, your predictions were in most instances wrong. Out of 8 results, you got five wrong: Homestead VR, Highland Park DW, Bellarmine BH, Strake Jesuit AW, and Lexington JZ all downed..On that level, you clearly have no place calling rounds–if anyone does. But, finally, nobody has a place to call the skills of another debater. Most likely, your predictions were based entirely on reputation, so you should probably stop trying to live your live vicariously through the success of others. It’s astoundingly tasteless, not to mention élitist, to “know” who will win a round. Your post is both.
I just want to know who the fuck you think you are.
Posted from: 208.54.35.208
January 9th, 2006 09:01
Rachel, Jennifer, and AJ are some of the strongest women in the world. Congrats!
Also, major congrats to Byron on a well-deserved bid and excellent showing.
Posted from: 66.218.240.111
January 9th, 2006 09:05
I hope the weather next year is similar to this year, and not last year’s rain and fog. It was nice to actually see the upper school at Brentwood before being told my round was perpetually up the hill.
Posted from: 151.202.39.91
January 9th, 2006 13:40
I don’t get the complaints about predictions. All the time, pundits predict who will win football games, often just for fun. Let’s assume that this isn’t something horrible and offensive.
It shares many of the characteristics of predicting rounds. The predictors weren’t at practices all week, and don’t know who’s in form and who’s not. They are based solely on past performances (although not necessarily only “reputation.” The predictor could have watched the teams/debaters previously, even in direct head-to-head matchups. So, the predictions are educated guesses based on the compartive strengths and weaknesses of the teams/debaters, along with an educated guess about what the round will be like, what the debaters will go for, etc.)
No pundit is claiming clairvoyance, in no way does making predictions about anything mean you have special powers (is the weather guy tasteless and elitist??)
It’s not really a big deal to me either way, but I don’t get the animosity towards the guy.
Posted from: 71.14.139.12
January 9th, 2006 14:36
Yeah VBT was chill. “Hella” props to Hess and Byron. Congrats to the Hockaday, Strake, and lynbrook armies for such a strong showing.
Congrats to Spirtos for not running the elipse K.
btw, strake jesuit DD=intense, especially considering he’s been debating for less than a year.
Posted from: 24.239.165.248
January 9th, 2006 14:41
CONGRATS STEPHEN!!!!!
Congrats to Peter, Pedrito (Lil Peter D) for clearing! NY love :)
Posted from: 72.64.123.231
January 9th, 2006 14:45
aww way to go Stephen Hess!!!!!
Posted from: 68.198.236.197
January 9th, 2006 15:01
SHESS!!!!!!!!
Posted from: 70.251.102.242
January 9th, 2006 15:03
I wanted to thank Victor and Mike and the Brentwood/Archer families and administration for both the round robin and tournament experiences. This was by and far one of the most enjoyable tournaments I’ve ever been too from the friendly atmosphere and hospitality to the educational rounds and feedback my students received. The consideration shown between the members of our community made our experience very worthwhile. Thank you.
Posted from: 68.196.115.198
January 9th, 2006 15:23
OMFG DID HOLLY HEISERMAN JUST POST ON THE VBD?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?! THIS CALLS FOR A CELEBRATION!!!
and yes, i did get completely pwnd by dudley and rene, but at least ill admit it unlike some of u other bitches on here. i guess it is UIL (which carroll completely owns in football every year) rules and that it is 2 sundays or whatever. but honestly i dont care considering i dont live in texas anymore.
Posted from: 24.160.101.171
January 9th, 2006 15:25
VBT was an excellent tournament.
Our school doesn’t like it when we miss class for debate tournaments.
Congratulations to Patrick for getting another bid.
Jeremy Dudley keeps track of our sunday tournaments.
Posted from: 24.0.219.224
January 9th, 2006 15:41
byyyyyyyron!!! congrats on a LONG deserved bid!!
Posted from: 24.16.112.123
January 9th, 2006 15:49
i’d say byron ruby is fairly legit. but that would be understatement. congrats dude
Posted from: 71.139.182.62
January 9th, 2006 15:57
VBT was a ton of fun. The atmosphere of the tournament was really cool, laid-back, and conducive to meeting new people and just having fun. I also wanted to congratulate some of the people I saw this weekend - obviously Stephen for getting his bid/winning and David Weeks for winning the RR, but also AJ (who I had never seen before) who was really impressive in finals, and Kevin Pratt and Caitlin Halpern, who both gave awesome and really intelligent performances when I judged them. I don’t think Kevin gets to travel much, and it’s too bad - he’s incredibly solid. Also, the Hockaday sophomore team is really intense - expect big things from them over the next couple years. Anyway, I hope everyone had as much fun as I did in LA.
Posted from: 69.151.225.0
January 9th, 2006 16:21
This tournament was amazing in so many ways.
First, the judging was superb and the round were well-administered. This is the first tournament where I can say the strike sheet was almost unnecessary. Though it doesn’t seem like much, I think that’s a huge complement—everyone who judged me had very strong credentials and tried their best to make honest and well-reasoned decisions. I was especially grateful that the ballots encouraged disclosures with critique, so I learned something new in every round. Needless to say, I—along with everyone else I talked to—was impressed.
Second, the people were great. The vbt staff was very helpful. It seemed like they were doing their best to make sure we were having a good time too. Everyone was approachable. Almost everyone was accepting of 80s dance music.
Third, the location is unmatchable. The weather was pristine—the sun was bright, and the temperature was perfectly balanced by the cool breeze. The schools themselves were really nice too: Archer is recognized as a historical landmark and Brentwood is like a hillside European village. But the best part of the location were the local attractions. The tournament hotel was on the Santa Monica pier, and we thankfully had time enough on Friday and Saturday night to explore the area. I’ve never been to a tournament where I liked the area so much. In fact, no other tournament can even hope to compete with Santa Monica in terms of pure swankness. None.
Finally, a few other highlights in no particular order:
-That damned amazing Italian place. Wow.
-For the sweepstakes awards, the top two teams received a director’s chairs with the vbt logo on the seat back. We are now members of the “Hall of Chairs”.
-NOT getting glass snowmen.
- “What is Love?” by Haddaway, “Barbie Girl” by Aqua, “La Vida Loca” by Ricky Martin, “Do You Believe in Life After Love?” by Cher, “Heaven” by DJ Sammy, “Eyes Like Yours” by Shakira, “Hung Up” by Madonna, and “Toxic” by Britney Spears, “Toxic (Armand Van Helden Remix)” by Britney Spears, “The Bad Touch” by the Bloodhound Gang, “Blue” by Eiffel 65, et cetera.
-Decking out in full UT gear when flying through LAX (Hockaday).
-Running the UT logo up the Brentwood flagpole (Strake).
- “Your team is like some sort of ‘debate frat’.”–Petey Gil
-A ton of others that I can’t remember.
Long story short: if you missed this tournament, you missed out.
Posted from: 69.149.74.189
January 9th, 2006 16:37
CONGRATS aj, i thought you did an A-M-A-Z-I-N-G job, considering we couldn’t really hear you from the little room we snuck into. ;) ;)
i really enjoyed vbt; the experience was amazing. most of my judges were really open to answering questions about strategy etc. as a sophomore, i’m trying to reach the “application” stage of knowing and understanding the flow game; a couple of my rfd’s really helped me understand. round five, actually, changed my life :)
thanks so much for running an awesome tourney, with awesome people and awesome competitors.
Posted from: 68.88.70.72
January 9th, 2006 16:44
vbt was soo much fun , some congrats:
first, aj !! my best thing , you made me so proud.
second, hockaday … i’m basically really excited about the sweepstakes chair.
third, strake - yall were fun and i look forward to the hockaday-strake alliance.
aaand finally, everyone. vbt was awesome! and the day that it wasnt, thanks to everyone who was so nice/ supportive
Posted from: 69.214.106.1
January 9th, 2006 17:09
jewtower is my hero!
congrats to patrick and aj too
Posted from: 216.103.211.238
January 9th, 2006 17:24
I’d like to echo all the comments here, although my 3-3 record certainly left something to be desired I was amazed by the quality of judging. Special props go to Kiwi for being hilarious, Navot for getting me anti-Micropolitics theory blocks, Hess for winning the tournament, Manjikian for continuing to pick me up on aff, and MSJ for a great dinner on Saturday night.
Posted from: 68.35.143.82
January 9th, 2006 17:51
I’m so happy for you A.J.!!!! Congrats! (I’m especially happy to have met all the Hockaday girls!) Hope to see everyone soon!!!
Posted from: 68.94.23.213
January 9th, 2006 19:14
first, a HUGE congratulations to AJ, rachel, and jennifer. all of you are AMAZING and are admirable in so many ways. thank you to everyone who put vbt, a phenomenal tournament, together and for being so considerate and caring throughout the weekend.
plus, props to byron for bidding this weekend. you deserve it.
Posted from: 71.131.250.139
January 9th, 2006 20:40
Congratulations to everyone especially Hess and Byron on some well deserved bids.
Posted from: 71.131.250.139
January 9th, 2006 20:42
Congratulations to everyone, especially Hess and Byron on some well deserved bids.
Posted from: 68.229.62.8
January 9th, 2006 20:46
dude, mad congrats to:
1) foudeh for double posting
2. byron and hess on bidding
3. and the strake team for dominating records
Posted from: 67.172.54.237
January 10th, 2006 07:10
I want to thank Victor, Michelin, Bietz and the rest of the VBT staff for running a fun, competitive and hospitable tournament. And big ups to Hess!
Posted from: 70.137.135.77
January 10th, 2006 07:32
Victor/Bietz/the VB Crew put on an amazing event - I don’t think I’ve ever had better judging at a tournament. I also want to thank everyone who had faith that I wasn’t a complete screw up.
Posted from: 24.6.251.224
January 10th, 2006 12:26
I love hess and byron :) you guys rock… congrats!!!!
Posted from: 207.193.176.61
January 10th, 2006 12:57
Can anyone fax (866-856-4354) the packet for me to use in the NDR?
Posted from: 72.130.183.145
January 10th, 2006 20:17
1. strake jesuit pm
2. lynbrook pd
3. hollis-brookline ah
4. mountain view sh
–
5. Westlake rc
6. Menlo-atherton br
7. hockaday am
8. rancho bernardo kp
9. strake jesuit aw
10. meadows ms
11. highland park dw
12. kinkaid bt
13. hockaday rb
14. Redlands jh
15. trinity prep rs
16. Lexington jz
17. strake Jesuit so
–
18. Bronx pp
19. homestead vr
20. bellarmine bh
21. wt woodson ch
22. la reina ct
23. Berkeley carroll pd
24. meadows dd
25. immaculate heart ak
26. strake Jesuit jc
27. Lynbrook cc
28. south Eugene js
29. strake Jesuit dd
30. la jolla es
31. hockaday jz
32. Menlo-atherton sa
im unsure about 8/9 (since i have neither a packet nor a really good memory of speaker awards save a few), but making kevin the 8 and andy the 9 seems more intuitive to me since then i will have judged the 9/24 and the 10/23 flights in doubles (which seems to make sense as a distribution).
Posted from: 71.9.20.79
January 10th, 2006 20:24
Mad props to Hess and Byron on picking up some madly deserved bids.
Also mad props to spirtos for continuing to represent our nsd lab with or without the elipsis K.
Posted from: 70.137.135.77
January 10th, 2006 21:13
Oh, I also want to say that Patrick Diehl (real diehl) is amazing and hasn’t ever lost a prelim in LD. That’s remarkable for someone coming late into the game. He’s also really pretty.
Posted from: 69.228.90.132
January 10th, 2006 21:19
that was stephen’s repayment for me sucking his cock
Posted from: 138.23.53.171
January 11th, 2006 11:16
yeah alex that’s right, kevin was 8th seed
Posted from: 65.255.204.67
January 12th, 2006 13:06
better late than never: congrats SHess and AJ
Posted from: 69.3.94.183
January 14th, 2006 14:42
nice patrick